The Open-air cinema · A film and a short essay
Why do people see the same situation so differently?
Your brother barely says a word at dinner. You think he’s being rude. Your sister thinks he’s exhausted.
Same man. Same silence. Two different stories.
A rather unusual biologist called Jakob von Uexküll might have something interesting to say about that. His starting point was a tick.
A short film about the worlds we inhabit, the things we notice and what we might be missing.
The same dinner
Same silence. Different stories.
Back to that dinner. On the way home you say, “He was in a right mood.” Your sister says, “Really? I thought he looked exhausted.” Try it from each side of the table.
What do you know that he doesn’t mention?
…
Pick what you know. The silence stays exactly the same.
You’re not simply interpreting the same behaviour differently. You have different things at stake. When you say “He was rude,” you might also be saying, “I felt rejected.” When she says “He was exhausted,” she might be saying, “Give him a break.”
Jakob von Uexküll, 1864–1944
A tick’s world
Uexküll was a biologist with a philosopher’s nose for a question, and his favourite example was the tick. To us, a forest is full of trees, birds, colours, sounds and smells. The tick lives in the same forest, but almost none of that reaches it.
All of this is here, deer included. Now switch to the tick’s forest.
Uexküll called this an Umwelt: the world that’s meaningful to a creature, shaped by what its body can sense and what it needs. Every organism, he thought, brings forth a world that matters to it. The idea went on to shape Scheler, Heidegger, Merleau-Ponty and Deleuze, and it quietly undermined the old picture of animals as little biological machines.
Humans obviously aren’t ticks. Although I’ve met a few people who come close. But we don’t encounter everything that’s happening around us either. Some things stand out. Others barely register.
It isn’t just opinions
Same invitation, different world
Your world shifts with your state, not just your beliefs. Move the slider.
Drinks on Friday?
“A few of us are going out. Come!”
The invitation hasn’t changed. What you notice, and how it appears to you, has. When you’re well, you can tolerate uncertainty, stay curious and see alternatives. As energy falls, perception narrows, and the world starts to look more threatening, more rigid and more black and white.
Before deciding who’s right
Separate three things
Here’s where I think this becomes really useful. Before arguing about who’s right, it helps to pull apart three things that usually arrive tangled together.
Of course, we could always ask him. Perhaps he really was being rude. Perhaps he was exhausted. Maybe both. Understanding somebody’s circumstances doesn’t mean excusing their behaviour.
And the fact that we experience things differently doesn’t mean all interpretations are equally good. Some fit what happened better than others. But it does mean we might want to be a little more curious before becoming certain.
Two questions to take with you
Two questions to take with you
What are they noticing that you’re not?
What are you bringing that makes it so hard to see anything else?
John Stoszkowski · Private Philosophy
Have a philosopher in your life
I spend my days reading, writing, teaching and getting lost in philosophy. Some people join me. We meet regularly, mostly online, explore extraordinary thinkers and see where the conversation takes us.
The transcript what I say in the film
Have you ever come away from a conversation wondering if you were even in the same room as everyone else? Same people, same event, completely different versions of what’s just gone on.
Let’s take the example of an ordinary family dinner. Let’s say your brother’s been a bit quiet, and has barely spoken all evening. And you think, “Oh God, he was in a right mood tonight. I don’t know what was up with him.” Maybe your sister says, “Oh, he looked exhausted. I thought he looked knackered.” You fell out with him last week; she knows his new baby’s been ill for the last few days. So it’s the same silence, the same him being quiet, and very different things stand out to people who were in the same room.
You might be thinking, “I feel a bit rejected. He just ignored me all night.” Maybe your sister’s thinking, “Give him a break. He’s had a hard few nights. He hasn’t slept much.” You’re in the same situation, just interpreting it very differently, and you’ve got very different things at stake in the relationship.
Now, this is where Jakob von Uexküll, a biologist with a really cool idea about how organisms experience the world, can help. The famous example he gave was the tick. So imagine a forest full of trees and birds and colours and smells and all that stuff. To us, that world looks really inviting, full of colour and movement and sounds and things going on. To the tick, Uexküll said, it’s pretty much just three signals: the smell of butyric acid, a temperature of 37 degrees, and physical contact with hair. They’re the three things the tick basically has in its world, because it’s looking for a mammal. It’s looking for the smell, the temperature and the hairiness of a mammal, so it can latch on and do what ticks do. So most of the forest that you can see has zero significance in the tick’s experience.
The term Uexküll used for this was Umwelt. We all have an Umwelt, which is essentially the meaningful world that you, as an organism, inhabit. It’s shaped by your senses and your relationships with your surroundings: not just different opinions, the whole thing. So different things in the environment are perceptible and meaningful to different organisms.
If we bring this back to human life, you’re obviously not a tick, but your experience is similarly selective. Even the same person can experience the same world very differently from one day to the next. One day your mates, or maybe someone at work, invite you out, and if you’re full of energy and feeling good, it’s “Brilliant, let’s go. I’m buzzing for this. Good night out.” If you’re a bit tired, you haven’t slept well for a few days, maybe you’ve got a cold coming on, it’s “Oh God, another obligation. I can’t be bothered with this. I’m knackered.” Same invitation, totally different possibilities standing out from it.
So if we go back to our dinner, before deciding who’s right, whether it’s you or your sister or your brother, you might ask yourself: what happened? Your brother was unusually quiet. What did you conclude? That he was rude, or angry, or exhausted. And what did you bring? Your history, your concerns, your expectations. You can obviously just ask him what’s up with him. But understanding perspectives isn’t the same as excusing behaviour, and it doesn’t mean everyone’s interpretation is equally good or bad. Perhaps just get a little bit more curious before you start becoming certain of what something meant, or what was actually going on.
Lightly tidied for reading. The quotations are from the translations named below.
If it’s caught your interest
Things to read
- A Foray into the Worlds of Animals and Humans (1934)Translated by Joseph D. O’Neil (University of Minnesota Press, 2010). Short, illustrated, and the home of the tick.
- Ed Yong, An Immense World (2022)A science writer’s tour of animal senses, built on Uexküll’s idea of the Umwelt. A very good read.
Elsewhere on Sheet 287
- Uexküll’s Meadow: a game in the Playground: see a meadow as a bee, a dog and a tick do
- Uexküll on the compass: and the thinkers who sit near him
A few minutes of philosophy