Back to the map

Private Philosophy · An essay you can poke at

Why don’t you have a philosopher?

Everyone’s heard of philosophy. Very few people have a philosopher. Here’s why I think that’s a bit strange, and what it’s actually like.

By John Stoszkowski, who is one. About eight minutes, with things to press.

Philosopher still free
At dinner

Two ways to answer a simple question

Someone across the table asks what you do. Here are two answers, both perfectly true. Watch where each one goes.

Conversation AThe accurate answer

ThemSo, what do you do?

MeI’m a philosophical coach. I help people challenge their assumptions and make better decisions.

ThemAh, right. Interesting.

(Conversation over. Someone passes the potatoes.)

Conversation BThe one that keeps going

ThemSo, what do you do?

MeI’m a philosopher. People have me in their lives. Some stay for a few months, others keep coming back for years.

ThemHang on. What do you actually do with a philosopher?

(The potatoes go cold.)

The first sounds like a service. It answers the question and closes it. The second opens one: what do you actually do with a philosopher? The rest of this page is my answer.

Notice it doesn’t mention a single problem.

A strange omission

The people we keep

Think of the specialists you have in your life, or have had. Tap the ones that apply.

A philosopherNot yet?

Tap the people you have, or have had.

We keep developing professionally all our lives. We take lessons, join clubs and seek out experts in music, art, sport and food. Yet our philosophical education, if we had one at all, usually ends before we’ve lived enough to see why it matters.

For a long time that would have looked odd. In the ancient world philosophy was a way of cultivating a life, and Roman households of means kept philosophers close, as teachers and as company. Somewhere along the way it moved into university departments and difficult books.

Not long ago, having a personal trainer sounded faintly ridiculous. Why should having a philosopher be any stranger?

What it feels like

Bring a thought

“Better thinking” and “sharper judgement” are promised by a thousand other things. It’s more useful to show you what actually happens.

Pick a thought that sounds like something you might say.

That’s the feeling. It’s hard to describe beforehand and easy to recognise when it happens. These aren’t questions you knew to ask, which is exactly why it helps to have someone around who does.

And it tends to want to happen again.

Got a thought of your own?Tell the compass what’s on your mind and it’ll point you to the thinker who’s been there before you, with a question to carry and somewhere to start.
The shape of it

A year with a philosopher

“Have a philosopher in your life” sounds lovely, but what would you actually be doing? Drag through a year. This one’s imagined, though it isn’t unusual.

Month 1

The shelf, so far

There’s no syllabus. Each conversation is shaped by the last one, and by what they’ve started to care about.

Somewhere around the fourth month, something important happened. The reason they came stopped being the reason they stayed. They’d found an interest that keeps generating new possibilities.

It’s hard to imagine before it happens, which is why I’d rather invite you in than ask you to name a problem for philosophy to solve.

Why would someone keep going for years? They haven’t finished learning.

The obvious objection

Why not just ask an AI?

You can get Nietzsche explained in seconds. Summaries of Kant are free, and there are more videos about Stoicism than anyone could watch. Information about philosophy has never been cheaper.

So why spend time with a philosopher at all? Because the pleasure was never really in the information.

What you can look up

  • An explanation of Nietzsche
  • Every idea, instantly
  • Answers to the questions you ask
  • Agreement, if you push for it

What builds up over time

  • Knowing which bit of Nietzsche you’ll resist, and why that’s interesting
  • The idea you dismissed in February, brought back in October when you’re ready for it
  • The questions you didn’t know to ask
  • Someone who’ll disagree with you, and mean it

There’s also a simpler point that gets overlooked: you’re spending time with someone whose company you enjoy. Most of the best experiences are the shared ones. Why should thinking be any different?

The longer answerWhy have a philosopher when you can ask AI anything? An essay with a painting that won’t explain itself, and one of Hume’s experiments to try.
A warning, and who enjoys it

Not an oracle

A philosopher isn’t someone clever to tell you what to think. If that’s what you come away with, I’ve done it wrong. I hope you’ll become increasingly confident questioning what I say, as well as what you read. Some of our best conversations will probably begin when you think I’ve got something wrong.

Unlike most professional relationships, this one should leave you more independent, not less.

You need me less to think, and enjoy me more to think with.

Who might enjoy having a philosopher in their life?

People who are curious about things. People who enjoy good books, interesting conversations, and discovering that something they’ve believed for years might not be quite right.

Some have read philosophy all their lives. Others wouldn’t know where to start. Some have difficult questions about the lives they’re living, while others simply want to find out what else there is to think about.

They don’t need much in common beyond an appetite for ideas.

Back at dinner

The sentence I’m after

“I’ve been talking about that with my philosopher.”

“Oh, interesting. I’ve been thinking about getting one.”

Imagine someone saying the first, without any self-consciousness at all. Then imagine the reply.

I’d like that to sound as ordinary as having a piano teacher. Not because anyone needs a philosopher, but because it’s a lovely thing to have.

John Stoszkowski · Private Philosophy

Have a philosopher in your life

I spend my days reading, writing, teaching and getting lost in philosophy. Some people join me. We meet regularly, mostly online, explore extraordinary thinkers and see where the conversation takes us.